Is Photography an Art?

On August 19, 1839, Louis Jacques MandeRomantics believed that so much detail didn't allow
Daguerre's photographic process was officiallyviewers to fantasize. Photographs left no room
announced at a joint public meeting of the Frenchfor imagination. In Romantic works, on the other
Academies of Science and Fine Arts. Shortly afterhand, boundaries between shapes were blurred.
that meeting, Susse Freres published a brochure,Detail was avoided. Forms were only suggested.
The History and Description of the Technique ofBrush strokes were evident.In other words, for
Daguerreotypy, which went into 26 editions in fivephotography to be accepted as an art form, it
months. Would-be photographers bought or madehad to stop looking like photography. So
equipment and began taking pictures of theirphotographers found ways to destroy what was
chimneys and counting the bricks.About the timephotographic about their photography in the hope
they were becoming tired of brick-counting,that their altered pictures would pass for some
someone said, "Chimney pictures are interesting,form of art. And these are some of the things
but is photography really art?" Some people arethey did.They found that they could manipulate a
still asking the question.Well, that's not exactly fair.picture either mechanically, when it was being
Most people made up their mind pretty quickly. Amade, or chemically, when it was being developed
camera was, to them, a machine that was to beor printed.Mechanically they could:* change the
used to record information, and photographersfocus during exposure (exposure times were
were machine operators. Early photographyvery long), thereby changing the depth of field*
shows reinforced this belief. The exhibitions weresoften the picture by use of a special lens* use a
associated with industry and not art, andpinhole instead of a lens* suspend a weighted
photographs were judged on their technical, notrope from the center of the tripod and create
their artistic, merits. The daguerreotypevibrations by running a violin bow over the rope*
competition at the world's fair of 1851 was wonplace a flame below the lens so that heat rising
by M. M. Lawrence. His pictures were judgedfrom the flame would cause visible wavesIn the
"remarkable for clear definition and generaldarkroom, the photographer could:* scrape, paint,
excellence of execution. ... Notwithstanding theiror draw directly onto the negative* place a special
large size, they are, throughout, perfectly in focus,sheet of glass between the negative and printing
and are beautifully finished in all details."Mostpaper to diffuse the light* use either glossy or
photographers were content to see themselvesrough printing paper* coat the printing paper, or
as technicians. But there are always a few peopleselected parts of the printing paper, with layers of
who don't get the word. To this minority,gum-based, toned emulsions, producing painterly
photography was definitely an art form, and theyeffects* use gum bichromate to rinse away
set out to convince the general public of this fact.details or even entire sections of a print. This
But how?A few pioneers reasoned that ifprocess allowed the artist to create deep,
photography was to be accepted as an art form,textured shadows and a grainy moodiness. As the
it had to look like other accepted art forms. Inoutcome of the gum-bichromate treatment
short, it had to look like painting. And,differed with each print, the photographer could
unfortunately for these well-intentioned pioneers,claim that each print was unique.This attempt to
the prevalent type of painting - the one they hadmake photos look like paintings was termed
to imitate - was Romanticism. So photographsPictorialism. The debate and the style continued
had to become emotionally intense, mystical,into the early 20th century.Edward Ginsberg is
melodramatic, brooding, somber, and exotic. Itcurrently writing a book to help the beginning
would also help if they were theatrical.As far asphotographer find true happiness as he embarks
technique, Romanticism was just the opposite ofon the road to creativity. Ed's photos can be seen
photography. Photographs showed great detail.on his website, where he also offers a free
They allowed people to count the bricks. Buttutorial.